I would put this in my nerd blog, but since I pretty much abandoned it, I’m going to just post it here.
I finally got a new cell phone last weekend. My Sony Ericsson p910a was approaching three years old and was completely falling apart so it was definitely about time. I kept waiting because I knew what phone I wanted and the manufacturer kept delaying it. I went with the AT&T Tilt (8925) which is an AT&T rebrand of the HTC TyTN II (a.k.a. Kaiser, a.ka. p4550). The wait was worth it though. It’s an amazing phone! It’s as close to being the Holy Grail of cell phones as exists right now. I wanted to wait until I had some time with the phone before writing up my review, but I think seven days is enough.
Here’s the spec list:
- 400Mhz processor
- 128MB RAM / 256MB ROM
- 2.8″ QVGA touchscreen
- slide out QWERTY keyboard
- GSM, GPRS, EDGE, HSDPA, UMTS
- Bluetooth and WiFi
- MicroSDHC expansion
- Built-in GPS receiver
- 3MP camera (no flash)
- Windows Mobile 6 Professional
Hardware
The device feels extremely solid in hand and the sliding mechanism is very smooth. The titling feature on the screen is a really nice addition over previous HTC phones. It allows for you to get a better angle on the screen while keeping your hands in a much more comfortable position. It also lets you place the phone on your desk and angle the screen up at yourself.
The scroll wheel on the side is very nice with just the right amount of resistance, but the travel when pushing it in seems a bit much. Unfortunately, I don’t think anything will top the scroll wheel on the p910a (it also tilted forward or back allowing three different clicking options). The buttons on the front face of the phone are nice and just the right size for small or medium sized hands, but if you have large fingers, some of the buttons might be a little small. The QWERTY keyboard is excellent. It’s very spacious and the buttons have just the right amount of travel and clickiness to them and do not require too much pressure. The only minor issue is that the buttons for the soft keys get to be a little hard to press when the screen is fully tilted. This doesn’t provide too much issue though because I rarely have the screen at full tilt while holding it and I can easily just touch the screen instead. The other issue with the soft keys is that they are a little close to rest of the keys and sometimes when typing an email or SMS, I’ll accidentally push the left one as I try to hit the ‘R’ or ‘T’ key. This causes my message to send before I actually want them to. To prevent this, I started typing my message before adding the recipients.
The phone comes with a decent sized stylus which was very welcome after using the almost microscopic one found on the p910a. I do find it a little annoying that it’s located on the bottom of the phone. This is especially annoying when I have the phone open and need to use my left hand to pull the stylus out and then have to hand it over to my right hand to actually use it. Fortunately, I find that I don’t need to use it that much. The 5-way navigation buttons on the front and scroll wheel along with my fingers take care of almost everything.
I would have liked a full sized SD slot, but since it seems that those don’t really exist on cell phones these days, I can live with the microSDHC slot. Unfortunately, the camera has no flash which sucks. It has decent low-light capabilities, but not having a flash does make it rather limiting, not to mention that an LED flash also doubles nicely as a flashlight. The camera itself is a little disappointing. For 3MP, I’d expect some better quality shots, but they are acceptable for a phone and the color isn’t too bad for what it is. If I were going out somewhere and I knew ahead of time that I wanted to take pictures, I would definitely want my digital camera with me, but this is more than acceptable for the random ad hoc shot.
The on-board GPS is really nice. This was the selling point for me as it’s the only PocketPC GPS phone with a QWERTY slider available right now. It is not a SiRFstarIII, but it gets the job done. When I first tried it, I was having a lot of trouble getting a fix and none of my apps would be able to get a reading, but an install of GPS Test did the trick and got it working. It gets a fix on satellites in anywhere from ten to thirty seconds. I don’t plan on using it much, but it’ll be nice for those few times a month that I drive to places I’ve never been to before.
I have two major gripes with the hardware though. The battery and the volume. The phone is not nearly loud enough for me. I would say that it easily needs to be twice as loud. Yesterday, I was trying to have a call while walking in NYC and the street noise made it very hard to hear the person on the other end. The call quality is very good when holding the phone up to your ear, but the speakerphone leaves a little to be desired.
The battery does not seem to last very long. At only 1350mAh, it does not carry enough power to give confidence that you will make it through the day. The GPS destroys the battery pretty quickly and about a half hour of use can easily take out 25%. I find this to be a bit expected though and I plan on plugging the phone in while in the car and using the GPS. I found that if I turned off the 3G data connection and kept my WiFi use to a minimum, I’d be alright. The phone got very heavy email and internet use all day yesterday with about a half hour of talk time and it got me through just fine, but had I not been able to charge it over night, I would not have made it through today. Do not plan on getting more than a day to a day and half out of this phone with just one battery unless you don’t ever take it out of your pocket.
Software
This is my first true experience with Windows Mobile other than messing around with some friends’ phones. My p910a had Symbian UIQ which is a very nice and aesthetically pleasing operating system, but it has a lot of limitations, especially in the syncing department. I find Windows Mobile to be a little clunky sometimes and on its own, it’s not very pretty looking, but this can be rectified with all of the tweaks and software support available online.
The integration with Windows is great, in my opinion. The syncing with Office is perfect in every way. The message handling on the phone is also great. I set it up with three personal accounts and my work email (via Exchange server) and I don’t have any real complaints about it. I love that it treats SMS/MMS messages just like emails as well. I have all of my email, contacts, tasks, and calendar entries all synced up between my phone, home computer and work computer. It doesn’t even require any effort to keep them in sync either.
The calendar, tasks, and contacts are much more robust and have many more options and fields than in Symbian.
The one thing that I didn’t like was that the phone came with AT&T’s bloated version of the ROM instead of the standard HTC one. There was a lot of bloatware and a lack of the HTC home screen plugin. I also read on a few sites that the AT&T ROM performs a bit slowly compared to the HTC one. So because of all of this, I flashed over to the HTC as soon as I got home from the AT&T store.
The black theme on the ROM is very nice and the home screen plugin is a neat addition, even though all of the functionality can be added through third party software. The HTC ROM also includes some TouchFLO elements, but I find that I hardly ever actually use the finger scro
lling.
Overall
Overall, I love the phone. I am very happy with it and it was definitely worth the wait. I would really recommend it to anyone who is looking for a full featured phone. There are a few minor quirks, but I really think it’s the best phone out there right now. When I got my p910 almost three years ago, I was excited that I could have my whole life right at my fingertips, but it never quite hit the mark for what I was looking for. With this phone, I can definitely say that I’ve got EVERYTHING I need.
Pros:
- Big, slide-out QWERTY keyboard
- On-board GPS
- Tons of third party apps available for Windows Mobile
- Great syncing with the PC
- Very solid build
- Tilting screen
Cons:
- A little sluggish sometimes, moreso than a phone with a 400Mhz processor should be
- Low call volume
- Poor battery life
- Only a QVGA screen instead of VGA
- No flash for camera
- A little thick for pants pockets
- No infrared port
And here is a list of all the 3rd party apps that I have installed so far:
- Tube 2
- Data on the Run
- CooTek TouchPal keyboard
- PocketCM keyboard
- SPB Pocket Plus
- SimCity 2000
- Lexisgoo English Dictionary
- Good FTP
- SPB Finance
- Telnet zaSFTP
- Pocket Mechanic
- AM Tasks+ Today Plugin
- PocketBlogger
- Calilei Calculator
- Vibra (switch)
- Tom Tom Navigator 6 (North American maps stored on microSD card)
- Bejeweled
- SPB Backup
- SPB Walled
- Resco Pocket Radio
- Hexacto Crossward Challenge
- GPS Test
- ConverterCE Pro
- RemoteAmp
- Resco Today Plugin
- Resco Registry Add-in
- Resco Explorer
- SOTI Pocket Controller
- KaiserNotification
- Google Maps
- IM+
- Pocket Hack Master
- Paul O’Brien P4550 Tweak Pack
- Mozilla Minimo
- Gmail
- SPB Time
- Opera Mini4 Beta
- Adobe Reader LE
- Excel Mobile
- Word Mobile
- PowerPoin Mobile
- PocketSNES
- PocketNESTER
- World Card Mobile
And all of this software is on internal memory except where noted. I still have plenty of space left.